Ive been wearing the Inika Organic Liquid Eyeliner in the shade of "Brown" for approximately a year with excellent results. Since I dont wear much in the way of cosmetics on a constant basis I usually wear it on the top eye lid either as a nude look or over a touch of eye-shadow & am always in a rush! Given ail of that I'm still very pleased with the results which never smudge, stay in place all day until sometimes late evening & never disappoint. The product comes with a wonderful liner which does a fabulous job of gliding on the eye lid either very slim or just as thick and perfect as demanded.